Why Butter Matters in Buttercream

If you’ve ever wondered why your buttercream won’t whip smooth, pipes too soft, or splits without warning — your butter could be the reason. As a pastry chef, one of the most common issues I see in home kitchens is butter quality holding back what could be a great frosting.

In this post, you’ll learn:

• What butter to choose for stable, silky buttercream

• How butterfat content affects texture

• My favourite pro tips for achieving consistent, stunning results

What’s the Best Butter for Buttercream?

Choose Butter with 82%+ Butterfat

The secret to smooth, stable buttercream? Butterfat.
Look for butter with a butterfat content of at least 82% — this creates a richer, less watery base, which means:

• Better structure

• Smoother consistency

• More stable piping

💡 Avoid:

• Supermarket butters with only 80% fat (especially in the US)

• Salted butter (alters sweetness and texture)

Grass-Fed Butter

Rich, flavourful, and golden — grass-fed butter gives your buttercream a depth that’s hard to beat. Bonus: it’s higher in omega-3s and vitamins too.

Organic or Cultured Butter

If clean ingredients matter to you, opt for organic or cultured butter. Organic butter has a purer flavour and fewer additives, while cultured butter adds complexity (a gentle tang that balances sweetness beautifully).

Want to Master Buttercream and Cake Finishing?

Learn exactly how to:

• Make silky, pipeable buttercreams

• Stack cakes with zero bulge or collapse

• Finish with smooth sides, clean edges, and elegant piping

📘 Join the waitlist for my new Buttercream & Cake Masterclass
🎥 Video tutorials, printable guides, and full technique breakdowns — coming this June.
👉 Join the Waitlist

Pro Tips for Flawless Buttercream

1. Room Temperature Butter – Soft but not melty

2. Scrape Your Bowl – Every few minutes for an even whip

3. Quality Extracts Matter – Use real vanilla (or your chosen flavour) for a finish that shines

Related Free Resource:

🎁 Download My Piping Guide for Mini Loaf Cakes
Learn how to use different piping tips for bakery-quality finishes at home.

Want 45+ Recipes for Fillings & Frostings That Actually Work?

If you’re tired of guessing your way through ganache, jam, buttercream or curd recipes — this is for you.

The Ultimate Guide to Cake Fillings & Frostings – Digital Download

Inside you’ll find:

• 45+ professional recipes (IMBC, ganaches, curds, jams)

• Quantity guides for cake sizes

• Seasonal flavour pairings

• Pro troubleshooting tips

👉 Get the eBook Now – Just $15

Recap: Butter That Makes the Difference

• Choose unsalted, high-fat butter (82%+)

• Prefer grass-fed, organic, or cultured varieties

With the right butter and techniques, your buttercream can go from soft and split to silky, stable, and showstopping.

Join My Baking Community

Sign up for flavour-forward, technique-rich baking inspiration — and get exclusive access to free downloads, early product launches, and masterclass news.

👉 Join the Newsletter + Freebies
Start with: Free Piping Guide or Cake Storage Made Simple